Nantucket Island invites vacationers with its charming blend of sandy shores and quaint, cobblestone streets. Beyond its picturesque beaches and Instagram-worthy sunsets, this island hides a secret not every traveler is privy to—it’s a treasure trove for wine lovers. A surprising revelation, Nantucket’s wine scene flourishes quietly alongside its more visible attractions.
From the annual Nantucket Food & Wine Festival to hidden gems like Epernay Wine & Spirits, BRIX Wine Shop, and the offerings of Nantucket Vineyards at Cisco Brewers, the island’s passion for fine wine breathes life into its rich, coastal experience. Seasoned oenophiles and curious beginners will find plenty to toast on Nantucket.
Embarking on a vineyard voyage unveils curated wine lists that could rival cosmopolitan hotspots. Leading the pack, Via Mare’s wine selection playfully categorizes its bottles with whimsical names, inviting intrigue and enjoyment. Phrases like “Cheerful & Huggable” reds or “White Burgundy: Nantucket’s Grape” not only spark interest but guide patrons through a thoughtful and adventurous journey of the palate.
From bold and familiar to the nuanced terrains of Beaujolais, Via Mare has intricately crafted a wine experience that promises delightful discoveries with each pour.
After its 2017 renovation, the Club Car emerged as a visionary in Nantucket’s wine scene. Offering an awe-inspiring variety of wines by the glass—from the verdant hills of Abruzzo and the vineyards of Napa to the sun-drenched terraces of Spain—every selection promises a testament to the globe’s rich viticultural variance. And with live piano music swirling around you, each sip seems to carry its own story, inviting you into a world where the wine flows as freely as the melodies.
Straight Wharf then ups the ante with a wine list that feels more like a curated exhibit of the world’s finest. Among its treasures, an impressive array of Grower Champagne stands out, signaling a commitment to showcasing producers who are as passionate about their craft as the restaurant is about its offerings.
This extensive and carefully selected wine list complements and elevates the dining experience, ensuring that each meal is as memorable for the glass in hand as for the plate in front.
For those inclined towards vinous voyages of discovery, Nautilus presents an award-winning wine list celebrated by Wine Spectator. This selection is an anthem to the adventurous, featuring wines from the unexpected corners of Switzerland to the distant vineyards of Peru.
Its “Diamonds in the Rough” collection encourages diners to explore the undiscovered gems of the wine world, transforming each visit into an exhilarating exploration of global viticulture.
Finally, Topper’s stands as a bastion of wine excellence. Its cellar boasts over 1,550 wines that pay homage to the sophisticates of the wine world, with a particular reverence for red and white Burgundy lovers. As a AAA 5-Diamond Restaurant Experience, Topper’s pairing of extraordinary cuisine with an unparalleled wine menu ensures a dining experience that beautifully captures the essence of coastal New England, one exquisite sip at a time.
Nantucket may be known for its lighthouses and laid-back beach vibe, but for those in the know, its wine lists are beacons of a different sort, guiding connoisseurs to unforgettable enological shores.
