In Nantucket Island lies a slice of Italy that locals and travelers alike cherish. Pi Pizzeria, with its rich history that threads back to its inception in 2006, was born from Evan Marley’s aspiration nestled in the backroom of a cozy wine and cheese shop in 2001. This endeavor to capture and preserve the essence of Neapolitan pizzas while adding a unique twist has morphed Pi Pizzeria into a neighborhood gem. Marley’s dream materialized into a reality, offering a space where the community could gather over a slice of pizza that carries with it the legacy of Napoli yet the distinct signature of Pi Pizzeria.

The Authentic Experience 

Marking a notable presence at 11 West Creek Road, Nantucket, Pi Pizzeria promises more than just a meal—it offers an experience. The intimate ambiance of the dining area, enhanced by the warm glow of the wood-burning oven, sets the stage for an authentic Italian-American culinary journey.

Guests at Pi Pizzeria are greeted with the tantalizing aromas of thin-crust Neapolitan pizzas being lovingly prepared alongside classic dishes that echo the rich tapestry of Italian cuisine. It’s a place where every bite tells a story, every dish a testament to the meticulous effort to maintain the integrity of classic recipes while embarking on a quest to make them distinctively ‘Pi.’

The Atmosphere 

Stepping into Pi Pizzeria, one is enveloped in an atmosphere that seamlessly blends the rustic charm of an Italian trattoria with the warmth of a neighborhood haunt. It’s not just about the food; it’s about the experience. The Italian-inspired bar within Pi Pizzeria, complete with an extensive Italian wine list and a selection of specialty drinks, serves as a vibrant social community.

Here, skilled bartenders, or ‘cocktailians’ as they’re fondly known, craft innovative concoctions that dance on the palate, embodying the spirit of Italian mixology. This unique blend of authentic dining and spirited camaraderie positions Pi Pizzeria as more than just a restaurant—it’s a slice of Italy located in the heart of our community.

For those in the neighborhood looking for a culinary escape to Italy without leaving the island, Pi Pizzeria offers an enriching experience. From its Neapolitan pizzas that honor tradition yet boast a personal flair to its comprehensive ambiance that marries Italian sophistication with local warmth, this pizzeria stands as a testament to the dream of its founder, Evan Marley. It exemplifies how a simple space in the back of a wine shop can evolve into a culinary institution, inviting everyone to partake in its continuous story—one delicious slice at a time.